Yes, agreed with you. Previously using performance air filter, the throttle body getting dirty quickly. The engine oil also get darken fast too. Now using OEM air filter, it provide better filtration and keep my throttle body clean and the engine oil slower brownish. But of course the performance of the car will drop in high rev.For me it is a YES. For example K & N filter (I use before). If you hold the filter in the air and look through the filter element you can see the pores/holes. If you hold up a OEM paper filter element you don't see any, that is why they filter better. K & N due to larger pores/holes they require oiling to help trap the dirt, that is why regular washing and re-oiling is required. Once the oil layer is covered with dust, it loses it's ability to trap, so more dust/dirt will go through....