@Tom
At first read, it feels you are too generous with the scoring. I guess we need to establish how your scoring works.
Is it the same scoring for ALL cars you review? If so a 7/10 power is ridiculously high for this car. As an example, a BMW 340i would come in at 7.5/10 and an A45S would be a 8/10 for power. And a C63S would be a 8.5/10 (the gap between the i30N & A45S is bigger versus the A45S vs the C63S) a Tesla Model S at 9/10? ... and a 911 Turbo S would be a 10/10? Then the new Tesla Roadster would be 11/10?
It would be utterly confusing if you have different scoring by car type/class. I think it should just be one ZTH scoring, and the cars are relative to each other. I think Doug Demuro's scoring makes more sense as it gives a sense of relativity to the audience.
So if the Kancil 660c is 1/10, the Axia 1000cc would be a 2/10..Myvi 1000cc would be 1.5/10.. a Myvi 1.5L would be 2.5/10, then this i30N would probably be around 5.5/10 - assuming a 330i is 5/10.
AND because this is called ZERO TO HUNDRED, I think scoring for each category should be based on ZERO TO HUNDRED, not ZERO TO TEN.
At first read, it feels you are too generous with the scoring. I guess we need to establish how your scoring works.
Is it the same scoring for ALL cars you review? If so a 7/10 power is ridiculously high for this car. As an example, a BMW 340i would come in at 7.5/10 and an A45S would be a 8/10 for power. And a C63S would be a 8.5/10 (the gap between the i30N & A45S is bigger versus the A45S vs the C63S) a Tesla Model S at 9/10? ... and a 911 Turbo S would be a 10/10? Then the new Tesla Roadster would be 11/10?
It would be utterly confusing if you have different scoring by car type/class. I think it should just be one ZTH scoring, and the cars are relative to each other. I think Doug Demuro's scoring makes more sense as it gives a sense of relativity to the audience.
So if the Kancil 660c is 1/10, the Axia 1000cc would be a 2/10..Myvi 1000cc would be 1.5/10.. a Myvi 1.5L would be 2.5/10, then this i30N would probably be around 5.5/10 - assuming a 330i is 5/10.
AND because this is called ZERO TO HUNDRED, I think scoring for each category should be based on ZERO TO HUNDRED, not ZERO TO TEN.